11
2010Life Could Be a Dream
As I contemplate my life – and it all seems so complicated – it occurs to me how simple life is in what I call Disneyland. Maybe, I’m thinking of Mayberry. Or is it Pleasantville?
Anyhow, whichever it is, a boy grows up there all wholesome and unconflicted, finds a local beauty to marry and live with happily ever after, has a satisfying job and 3 kids that came to be in the purest of ways. Everybody is happy. Days are spent in productive efforts and politically correct conversation, and the community thrives. In time, they will grow old and wise, and be surrounded with generations of family and friends, until they slip peacefully into the great beyond, with a contented smile on their faces.
Of course, this is fantasy, but the question is, “By how much?”
I sometimes see certain people on the street that look to me to have come straight out of such a scenario. No doubt, I am projecting, but when I see a young, rosy-cheeked woman in a modest but pretty dress, with a wedding ring on her finger and a necklace with a cross, smiling as she gracefully makes her way to her destination, I wonder…
So, Why Not Me?
Why do I make things so hard on myself? Why do I try to explore all the options, to color outside the lines, to reinvent the wheel? Maybe blissful ignorance and faith in the tried and true is the real path to lasting happiness?
That is, after all, a major drawing card of devoted religion. There is belonging and community and purpose, and guidance.
By contrast, here I am at middle age – variously, a guy with inappropriately long hair, a woman with the wrong sex-parts, a man with no children, a person of uncertain sexual orientation and appetites, belonging nowhere…
Now, that doesn’t sound good at all, does it?
And, the thing of it is that for all intents and purposes, I believe that I choose to be this way: part-time girl, part-time boy. I am not victim of gender dysphoria, and I do not have to do this.
Rather, I am simply being open to all the sexual and gender possibilities because I want to experience as much as possible and see what I like. It is about passion and interest and variety and possibilities – and, to be clear, this attitude goes well beyond the sexual…
One Life to Live
The thing about possibilities, though, is that they are the opposite of commitment.
I certainly do not regret insisting on exploring the myriad of possibilities that might enhance and color my life, rather than accepting, without challenge, so-called black & white rules of life.
But, I think my problem is a failure, or inability, to commit to those possibilities. And that is what has left me adrift…
Petra Bellejambes
Well, dear Janie.
First off, nice to see you back in print after a long(ish) time away.
Second, interesting to me that you place possibility and commitment on seemingly opposing ends of a continuum. You may be on to something, but I would love a little more convincing. You see, I have always found that commitment to a choice opened up possibilities. Yes, of course, other possibilities are closed off with each choice, but in the context of your note today, those possibilities seem to be a little more conventional, a little more default, and while you may periodically envy their simplicity, a little less Janie.
As far as choice goes, I am not sure that we, any of us, really choose it all. By this I mean that perhaps you (or I for that matter) did not choose to be part-time this or that. Perhaps you (and I hope, I) chose rather to recognize that this is simply how it is for us. You have bits of boy, and bits of girl, and you nurture them both as a matter of choice.
You (and methinks I, and many other of your friends here) chose to commit to that recognition, and act on it accordingly, faithfully and with all the fidelity that others commit to other paths.
Hooray!
I do sympathise with your stated sense of being adrift. I feel it too. I suspect much of that feeling comes from the reality that there are fewer standard bearers of excellence, fewer shining examples of what we can aspire to. That rosy-cheeked woman in the modest but pretty dress, with a wedding ring on her finger, well she had avatars all around her. Fewer avatars on view to us, yes? Hard not to feel adrift at moments.
Looking forward to the continuation of this post m’dear.
Cheers – Petra
cdjanie
Well, Petra, you shall see that I have been a lot more mixed up and conflicted than that, as the subsequent parts will show.
But, I really like your point about avatars – as usual, you are three steps ahead of me! I have recently become quite sensitized to the myriad examples on view of what we ought NOT aspire too, and this has troubled me to no small extent. I ask myself,”Is this me? I hope not.”
Cassie
Well Janie…
I’m just a misfit.
Literally.
I really loved Marilyn in that movie!
Rachelle Bellamy
Hi Janie
I am inclined to agree with Petra about your commentary on choice. I am not convinced either that you have as much choice in these matters as you would like to believe. Do any of us have any real choices is even a bigger question? It is the American ethos to believe what we are the masters/mistresses of our destinies. But you don’t have that excuse since you are Canadian… 🙂 You imply you could choose a “straight” life. I am doubtful. I find myself asking some of the same questions. When I am thinking about it it seems like maybe I have those same choices…. But when I read your assumptions about choice, I can see through it as a false distinction. But of course, my problems are uniquely special while everyone else’s are clearly resolvable…. 🙂
Rachelle
cdjanie
Sure, gang up on me…
I’ve missed your wit, darling.
It is not so much a question of whether we are masters of our own destinies as whether this thing is part of my gender makeup or a hobby, like bowling (to quote a mutual friend). You CAN choose whether or not to do a hobby, can’t you? Even if it is fun…
For my part, I am just asking the question – and quite frankly, things will be a lot easier for me if this is part of my gender makeup. I like being Janie, and if it is not just a hobby, then I am justified in pursuing it even if it isn’t a “smart choice.” A “License to Frill” if you will 😉 All the guilt goes away and I am free. However, if it is a choice, then I must take responsibility for it, consider the pros and cons, and so on. And, I don’t want to allow myself to take the easy road unless I am convinced I have that right.
Rachelle
I like the bowling metaphor. That must explain why I have discovered breasts growing on my chest… I should be bowling more… 🙂
How do you answer the question of dressing as hobby (and the resulting consequences) or dressing as need or expression of some inner identity (and the resulting consequences)? When looking around at the model avatars there are those who’s GID is as clear as the hair on their head. Those are tortured souls that are only relieved of their suffering by fully embracing their inner sense of gender. But even in these cases, I don’t think anyone really understands how the GID came to be. Regardless of how many are like this, there are others whose reasons to play with gender are not so clear. But given the complications in brings into one’s life to break the rules of gender binary, I can’t believe that it is purely a “choice” in the bowling sense of the word. It is too complicated and too satisfying to just be a choice like a hobby. However, that does not really help to explain what it is either.
Rachelle