27
2011Risky Business
(…continued from Missed It By That Much)
I ran into the wife of a friend of mine, in a place where and at a time when I often would go as Janie; fortunately I was in guy mode. She happened to mention that she frequents a nearby cafe for lunch that I have often gone to as Janie (though never at lunchtime).
So, I missed being discovered by the skin of my teeth, now what?
Nobody said life as Janie would be dull, right? (…kinda the point… though I can do without this particular kind of excitement.)
Clearly, if she had “caught” me, all my friends would have known in fairly short order. Once a wildfire starts spreading, it is difficult to contain, so it is impossible to know how far the flames would have spread.
By the 6 degrees of separation theory, it is more than a little possible that the news would reach the ears of people I absolutely do not want knowing.
Dealing with my friends would not be optimal, but I would cope. There would be changes, to be sure, but who knows how things come out the other end? People often surprise you.
But certain people don’t – and those are my bigger worry. Again, I’d survive, but I’d much rather not have to go through that.
So, is it worth the chance I am taking to be able to freely walk the streets?
Risk Assessment
First, let’s better assess the risk. Remember, she called to me from behind; what are the chances that she would have thought it was me if I had been in female clothes? It is easy to recognize a guy you know with long red hair – he presents a distinctive target for one’s eye; but as a woman, I am just another redhead.
Ah, but she could just as easily have been in front of me. True. But, then I would likely have seen her and taken evasive action or at least walked quickly by. I certainly wouldn’t have responded to her.
And, she would have been left with, at worst, this sneaking suspicion that maybe, “Could that have been him? Nah!!”
Context plays a big part in recognition, so that even in these circumstances, being caught dead-to-rights is unlikely unless I give it away on purpose or by accident. No one is going to readily assume something that is opposite to everything they know about you based on a momentary glance.
Of course, seeing me sitting in a cafe, stationary and trapped – that’s a different story…
Obviously, there’s risk – it is not like I didn’t know it before. But, to avoid that risk means staying at home as a girl, or just going out to t-friendly bars that way.
I don’t think that works for me.
Risk’s Rewards
To be honest, I often get more pleasure from walking on the street in a sundress and sandals in the summer than going out to a bar. There is a freedom, and a normalcy about just being that I love.
Being Janie is not about wearing a costume or a sexual fetish; it is just my way of living. That is why I cherish doing everyday things as much as and maybe more than going out on the prowl.
I have been duly chastened, however. And, the thing that has hit home is that playing at this is a dangerous game.
I need to make a decision about where this is leading, and soon, before the worst happens: I end up outed before deciding that I’m better off just being a guy.
I need either to commit to my girl self for the long haul or give it up before I fall into the abyss.
Edy
Hi Janie,
It is always challenging for us to decide who to tell and not to tell. My situation is deemed a little less complicated because I am single now and don’t have to worry about my partners feelings regarding who to tell. Nevertheless, being trans creates dilemmas that we must address in our search for living an authentic life. I for one made the decision to live an open life. I had to move to feel more comfortable in a place I felt more accepting, but I am determined to live an openly transgender life. I have recently told some of my long term friends about me. They were very accepting and comforting. But I pick my battles. My conservative family is on the back burner. Maybe one day if I go fulltime then they are going to have to know, but not right now. I made the decision recently that any new friends that I make will know all of me. I cannot live in fear of being found out. I have nothing to hide or be ashamed of.
cdjanie
That’s very courageous, Edy, and likely to repay you many times over in terms of psychological and even everday practical benefits.
My situation seems to be a bit different than yours in the sense that I cannot pick my battles, so to speak… that the people I know are so closely intertwined that if one finds out, everyone will know. So, it is all or nothing for me.
But I don’t live in fear of being found out either – I can’t fathom that. I just do what I do…
Ashley
To echo Edy. If you come out to your friends and family voluntarily, then YOU control the information and the timeing and the dissipation. If you get “caught” by a talkative friend, then you’re no longer in control.
However, I think you need to make some assessment of where this is all going. You said:
“Being Janie is not about wearing a costume or a sexual fetish; it is a way of living. That is why I cherish doing everyday things as much as going out on the prowl”.
Which sounds to me that Janie is going to be hard to give up. Rather, I think you need to sit with a professional and really see where your feelings truly lie.
cdjanie
Ashley, in my personal situation, the control of the information and dissipation makes very little difference. But, please understand that, in the greater sense, the posts I make about my life and my feelings and challenges are not so much about me and solving my problems as they are about sharing experiences so that we can all learn from each other. With that in mind, anything that pertains specifically, uniquely and personally to me is not really the focus here.
That said, I thank you again for your concern and advice. And yes, being Janie would be hard to give up – but I am not trying to give it up. What I am doing is trying to make sense of it all. Together with everyone else.
Alice
Well I just have to say have fun be yourself. If she were to see you so you could tell her to please not say any thing and maybe gain a female friend who would like to have coffe with Janie sometimes. It’s a shame that we as a society are so closed minded that we can’t accept a guy who dresses I’n girls clothes but for a female to dress in pants and a button down us accepted. Go figure?
cdjanie
Thanks for your comment, Alice. Juicy gossip like that is hard to contain; your idea would be a magical fantasy, but it is unrealistic – at least in this case, knowing the person involved.
As to why women can wear pants but men cannot wear skirts, I think it is as simple as this: it is different for someone who is strong to show weakness than it is for someone who is weak to show strength. Whether or not this is a fair assessment of the sexes (men strong, women weak), whether or not it is politically correct, I believe this mentality is what underpins the different treatment of men and women in this regard.
shantown
Agreed, Janie. The Village People said it best long ago……
“Macho, macho man….I”ve got to be..a macho man.” Our society is severely hung up on “macho man syndrome”….IMHO. Guys who do not exude macho toughness are looked down on many times. Heaven forbid they should show up in heels and a skirt too. It is not fair, or PC, as you say….it is just the reality of the situation. Personally, I think it all sucks!
cdjanie
Well, Shannon, you may hate me for this, but I actually feel that way about masculinity. Not so much “macho” but a fairly traditional view of what masculinity is – strong, stoic, reliable, courageous, etc.
shantown
Oh, I don’t disagree with that “definition” of masculinity……but what about guys who don’t, for whatever reason, fit that mold. How does society….how do you…..view them? I have no problem that it exists, but it is just one segment of society, and should not be expected of all….and those who don’t fit shouldn’t be automatically looked down on. As was said earlier, women can dress “manly” in many acceptable ways, but the “effeminate man” is almost universally looked down upon. Nothing wrong with strong, stoic, courageous, etc.,but what happens when society doesn’t viiew me that way.? How am I treated then? On a side note, I personally think that those girls venturing through the TG waters, especially those going through transition, probably have more courage than any macho guy could ven fathom.
cdjanie
I’d first like again to draw the distinction about “macho” vs masculine. Macho is often a cover for lack of masculinity. And, you are right, of course, that being T takes a fair bit of courage.
Just because a woman can dress “manly” doesn’t mean she can act “manly.” A woman who acts like a man runs into about the same resistance in society as a man who acts feminine. Don’t you think so?
As to your main question, everyone should be treated with respect and compassion, and the understanding that the variation in the human experience makes society more interesting and also more productive.
shantown
Totally agree on the “macho” thing. I think the world is full of examples of “macho” guys who turned out to be gay. Also agree on the manly woman issue…..but that leads to another double standard we face. A woman can dress “manly”, but as long as she still acts in accepted feminine ways, she is accepted. A guy, though, can act as manly as he wants, but if he’s wearing women’s clothing, he’s not going to be accepted. So, for women, acceptance is based on actions, not clothes, but for men, acceptance starts with the way they look and dress, not how they act.
Just sorta thinking out loud there, venturing thoughts for discussion.